0
Views
0
Downloads
0.0
0
Save
0 Likes
Evaluating Sources: Credible or Not Credible Worksheet
0 Views
0 Downloads
Paste this activity's link or code into your existing LMS (Google Classroom, Canvas, Teams, Schoology, Moodle, etc.).
Students can open and work on the activity right away, with no student login required.
You'll still be able to track student progress and results from your teacher account.
Information
Description
What It Is:
This worksheet guides students through evaluating source credibility using higher-level critical thinking skills. In Part 1, students determine whether academic, governmental, personal, and sponsored sources are credible or not credible. In Part 2, students write a short constructed response explaining their evaluation using formal criteria such as author expertise, evidence quality, bias, purpose, and publication source.
Why Use It:
This activity prepares upper high school students for college-level research, academic writing, and standardized assessments. It strengthens analytical reasoning, supports evidence-based argumentation, and helps students develop responsible research habits in an age of misinformation.
How to Use It:
• Have students independently evaluate each source description in Part 1.
• Require students to justify their decisions using academic reasoning.
• In Part 2, have students write a 3–4 sentence response using at least two credibility criteria.
• Use responses for assessment, discussion, or research skill reinforcement.
Grade Suitability:
Best suited for Grade 11 to Grade 12.
• Grade 11: Developing advanced research evaluation and academic justification skills.
• Grade 12: Preparing for college-level research, argumentative writing, and source analysis.
Target Users:
Ideal for high school ELA and social studies teachers, AP and honors instructors, homeschool educators, and students preparing for post-secondary academic research.
This worksheet guides students through evaluating source credibility using higher-level critical thinking skills. In Part 1, students determine whether academic, governmental, personal, and sponsored sources are credible or not credible. In Part 2, students write a short constructed response explaining their evaluation using formal criteria such as author expertise, evidence quality, bias, purpose, and publication source.
Why Use It:
This activity prepares upper high school students for college-level research, academic writing, and standardized assessments. It strengthens analytical reasoning, supports evidence-based argumentation, and helps students develop responsible research habits in an age of misinformation.
How to Use It:
• Have students independently evaluate each source description in Part 1.
• Require students to justify their decisions using academic reasoning.
• In Part 2, have students write a 3–4 sentence response using at least two credibility criteria.
• Use responses for assessment, discussion, or research skill reinforcement.
Grade Suitability:
Best suited for Grade 11 to Grade 12.
• Grade 11: Developing advanced research evaluation and academic justification skills.
• Grade 12: Preparing for college-level research, argumentative writing, and source analysis.
Target Users:
Ideal for high school ELA and social studies teachers, AP and honors instructors, homeschool educators, and students preparing for post-secondary academic research.
